Casey is originally from the greater Philadelphia area but currently resides in central Pennsylvania. She attended Lock Haven University where she studied Interdisciplinary Studies with concentrations in middle level education and communications.

During her time at Lock Haven, Casey was a walk on to their NCAA Division II Softball team her Freshman year as a middle infielder and continued to play for them until the end of her Sophomore year. After completing 2 years with the Lock Haven Softball team, Casey went on to found the Lock Haven Softball Club alongside Camryn Lang. Along with co-founding that team, Casey was also their Vice-President and head coach. During that time, her and Camryn were able to lead the team to a conference championship. The foundation on which they build the team still stands strong as the team has continued with a winning season even while under new leadership.

Casey is still involved with Softball to this day as she traveled with the NCSA to Columbus Georgia in 2025 for the Division 1 World Series and in 2026, she was the Regional Director for the District 2, Division 2 Regional tournament. Casey is also heavily involved in adult fastpitch leagues in central Pennsylvania.

Casey is devoted to athletics and she shows that creating a welcoming and fun environment for fellow athletes. Outside of softball, she enjoys reading, hanging out with friends, visiting her family and spoiling her dogs.